Terms of Reference (ToR)
CEN-CENELEC-ETSI Joint Technical Body eAccessibility

(APPROVED VERSION BY THE CEN-CLC-ETSI/JWG R&P)

2022 Proposal, v1.2. Version agreed at the 2022-06-22 JWG meeting. DOCUMENT N601

1. Title
CEN-CENELEC-ETSI Joint Technical Body (JTB) eAccessibility.

2. Scope
To develop standardisation documents common to CEN, CENELEC and ETSI in the field of the accessibility of ICT products and services.

3. Status
The CEN-CENELEC-ETSI Joint Technical Body (JTB) eAccessibility is a Joint Technical Body (JTB) according to the provisions of the CEN-CENELEC-ETSI Basic Co-operation Agreement, Annex 2, Mode 5
NOTE 1 The 2022 version of Mode 5 approved by the CEN-CLC-ETSI Joint Presidential Group is given in Annex A of this document.
NOTE 2 The secretariat will inform the Joint Technical Body (JTB) whenever the Co-operationAgreement between the ESOs is modified.

4. Rules for standards works
The works of the CEN-CENELEC-ETSI Joint Technical Body (JTB) eAccessibility are under the Mode 5 of collaboration referenced in clause 3 of this document, with the specificities described in points 5 and 6 below.

5. Chair and Vice-Chair election process
The Mode 5 of collaboration referenced in clause 3 of this document states the following: “The appointment of the JTB Chair shall be organised by the JTB secretariat according to the rules and procedures of the ESO it is affiliated with, except for the provision that exist in the present document and that take precedence. The appointment of the JTB Chair shall be endorsed by the JTB and the JPG following the principle described in Article 1 (i.e. on the basis of a consensus established between the positions of the Technical Boards of the European Standardisation Organisations (ESOs) involved).”

According to DECISION 4/2021 taken by CEN-CENELEC-ETSI JWG eAccessibility on 2021-09-23, the process to elect Chair and Vice-chair(s) of the JTB eAccessibility is the following:

  1. The secretariat opens the call for candidates within the JTB (3 weeks).
  2. The secretariat makes all nominations known to the JTB participants (members + observers).
  3. The secretariat considers all proposals and tries to reach consensus on a candidate, for nomination by the JTB’s members, approval of the CEN and CENELEC Technical Boards and ETSI Board, and final endorsement by the Joint Presidential Group (JPG).
  4.  Once the Chair has been appointed, the same process applies for Vice-Chair(s).

This procedure is compatible with the one described in Mode 5 of collaboration.

6. Accessibility of the standardisation process
The CEN-CENELEC-ETSI Joint Technical Body (JTB) eAccessibility is committed to inclusion and a high level of accessibility in communication, proceedings, meetings, venues and documents, as well as reasonable accommodation to JTB participants.


Annex A

Mode 5 of co-operation – Integrated relation


1 Joint technical work between CEN-CENELEC
Clause 4.2.1.3 of the CEN/CENELEC Internal Regulations - Part 2 applies.

2 Joint technical work with ETSI participation

1. Creation of the JTB: The creation of a Joint Technical Body (JTB) between CEN, CENELEC and ETSI (or between ETSI and CEN or CENELEC) and its Scope and ESO providing the Secretariat shall be agreed upon by the European Standardisation Organisations (ESOs) based on a co-ordinated recommendation by the Joint Presidents’ Group (JPG).

2. JTB Secretariat: The ESO providing the JTB Secretariat shall identify the Secretary according to its own procedures. If the allocated ESO withdraws as JTB Secretariat, another ESO shall be selected to provide the Secretariat according to Article 1.

3. JTB Chair & vice-Chair(s): The JTB shall appoint the JTB Chair from one of the candidates nominated by the members of the JTB according to the rules and procedures of the ESO providing the Secretariat. The provisions regarding mandate period in this agreement apply to the JTB. 
In their duties of conducting discussions and JTB meetings, and guiding the secretariat, the Chair and the Vice-Chairs (if any) shall maintain strict impartiality and shall divest themselves of their organization, ESO, or personal point of view.
The JTB Chair shall be appointed for a 2-year mandate period.
The JTB may take a decision to re-appoint the JTB Chair for one additional term of up to two years. If the JTB has not decided to re-appoint the existing JTB Chair by a date three months before the end of the mandate period, it shall call for nominations for a new JTB Chair to all participating ESOs and shall take a decision to appoint the new JTB Chair according to the provisions of this article.
The JTB may also appoint vice-Chairs according to the provisions of this article. 
If a Chair or vice-Chair resigns the JTB shall appoint another according to the provisions of this article.
If the JTB is not successful in taking a decision to appoint the JTB Chair, it shall request the JPG to make a co-ordinated recommendation to be submitted to the ESOs for decision.

4. Participation in the JTB. Participation in the JTB shall be open to the members of the involved ESOs (Full and Associate members in the case of ETSI and national delegations formed by the National Standard Bodies (NSB) and National Committees (NC) in the case of CEN and CENELEC). Organisations participating to the JTB as ESO members shall indicate to the JTB secretariat under which involved ESO(s) they participate.
Representatives of the European Commission and EFTA (ESOs Counsellors) and Annex III organisations may participate in any JTB technical or organisational discussions in the JTB without the right to vote and according to the rules of the ESO providing the JTB Secretariat.
The JTB may take a decision to invite representatives from other bodies to participate without the right to vote. The JTB Chair may exceptionally invite additional participants to join a specific JTB plenary meeting as Observers, should it be relevant to support the JTB work. Observers invited under the provisions of this article may participate to any JTB technical or organisational discussions on the invitation of the JTB Chair without the right to vote.

5. Decision-making within the JTB: ETSI Full and Associate members and the national delegations formed by the NSBs and NCs of CEN and/or CENELEC shall be authorized to participate to the decision making in the JTB.

6. JTB Work Programme: The JTB shall draft its work programme, clearly indicating the leading ESO for each work item, for which the drafting rules of the leading ESO shall be applied. The work programme of the JTB, including the assigned leadership of each work item, shall be approved by the ESOs involved. In the case of work in response to an EC/EFTA Standardization Request) the decision is taken in each ESO according to their procedures complying with Regulation (EU) 2022/2480. The work programme is circulated to the JPG for information.

7. Decision making by consensus: A JTB shall operate and take decisions based on the consensus reached amongst the participating members of the involved ESOs. The Chair shall make every effort to obtain consensual decisions within the JTB, whilst maintaining neutrality. The Chair is responsible for assessing whether consensus has been reached. If consensus cannot be reached due to sustained opposition(s), the Chair may decide to trigger a vote (in line with article 9). If any ESO disagrees with the ruling of the Chair, it may raise the question to the JPG for a co-ordinated recommendation by the Joint Presidents’ Group (JPG) to the ESOs for a decision.

8. Voting in the JTB: When the Chair identifies the need to trigger a vote, the JTB Secretariat shall announce the vote and provide all necessary information to the JTB. This vote shall be run concurrently by each involved ESO according to its rules and procedures. The vote shall run for a duration that is
agreed by the JTB, considering the ESOs rules and procedures. A minimum of two weeks is recommended. Each ESO shall communicate its position – abstentions are not allowed. At the end of the voting period, the JTB secretariat shall collect the results of the votes organized by each involved ESO and shall share the results within the JTB. A vote of the JTB shall be considered as successful only in case of unanimity i.e. the involved ESOs having individually collected a favourable vote under their own rules and procedures. In case the outcome of the vote is not successful, the matter shall be deferred to the ESOs involved.
NOTE: co-ordination by the JPG is not proposed in this case.

9. Approval of Joint publications: The decision to request approval of a draft EN by the ESOs involved shall be taken by the JTB. The enquiry and its associated national vote, and the subsequent steps shall be organized by each involved ESO in accordance with its rules and procedures, and in coordination
with the other ESO(s) involved (see annexed flowchart). A draft shall be considered as accepted only if approved by all ESOs involved according to their own rules and procedures. If this is not the case, the draft shall be referred back to the JTB for further consideration. Joint deliverables other than ENs shall be approved by consensus (see point 8).

10. Copyright and distribution rights. The involved ESOs shall have a joint ownership of and a joint copyright on the (draft) publications that will hence bear the corresponding logos, for which each involved ESO shall ensure the distribution in accordance with its rules and procedures included in a separate document.

11. Maintenance of Joint Publications: The involved ESOs are jointly responsible for the maintenance of the joint publication and shall allocate this task to the corresponding JTB, if still active. In case the JTB had been disbanded, the maintenance of the publication shall be placed under the coordinatedresponsibility of a relevant joint group designated by involved ESOs according to article 1. Any issue related to the maintenance of any JTB publication may be brought up to the attention of the ESOs concerned.